Title shamelessly stolen from this song.
I remember the feeling of your hands on mine where we knelt opposite one another, our bare knees pressed against the linoleum gym floor. You guided my hands to the stacks of plastic cups, showing me where to place one so that it balanced atop two others balanced atop three more. You sat with me until I could find the spaces without hesitation, until you could do it with your eyes closed. You sat with me until I was just as fast as you, and you were the fastest of all of us. We competed against one another endlessly, our laughter tangling with the sound of plastic collapsing and scattering, and it never mattered who won.
I remember the call for us to line up at the end of recess, how my giggling friends would abandon me once I was at your side. I remember slipping my hand into yours and waiting, giddy and eager, for you to comment on it. You wouldn’t say anything. You carried on with your conversation, your fingers tightening around mine, until I inevitably pointed out the fact you were holding my hand. Such a gesture was novel, exciting, unthinkable to our young minds and innocent hearts. I knew it meant something to be holding yours, and I wanted you to recognize it. Your quiet acceptance and reciprocation were a form of communication far beyond my comprehension at the time.
I remember you played the drums. I decided I wanted to, too. I joined the talent show, my band formed from my uncle and his own, far more mature band members. I owned that stage with them, the star performance that out shown all others. It’s almost unfair, looking back. There was no competing against the girl with a whole band alongside her. I remember you hugging me afterward, so proud of me even though I’d played a minimal role in the whole act.
I remember you giving me the small card still taped to the inside cover of my first ever personal phone book, just weeks before I moved out of the state. It has your name and your phone number, scrawled in your mother’s careful hand. I would later trace my fingers across the smooth surface, wondering at the shape of the letters and the spelling that they created. I realized I didn’t know your last name. I knew the outline of it, the sound it might have made when the teacher called on you, but the exact makeup of it eluded me.
We talked a few times, mostly over the summer between fifth and sixth grade. I remember the unbearable, painful shyness that invaded my lungs and coated my throat with needles. “It’s your turn to ask a question,” you said, the sound of a basketball hitting the pavement in your background. I froze. I was too scared. I didn’t know what to say. I didn’t want to lose you, and it felt like the next words that came out of my mouth were going to make or break that possibility. I remember how the walls felt like they were closing in around me, from where I sat on our stairs’ landing, the furthest Mom would let us have a private conversation. I don’t remember what I said. I don’t remember if I asked a question. I just remember your voice, punctuated by the basketball hitting the pavement: “It’s your turn to ask a question.” I wouldn’t talk to you again for nine years.
You still somehow lingered. You were the boy who my young heart had fallen for. You were the first crush and the one lost to time and burgeoning anxiety. You were the one who was half-formed, never fully realized. You were the one who became the basis for every story I ever wrote, every daydream I ever had. You were the one who never was, but who became everything. You were a boy of skin, bones, breath, and blood, but you were a thousand possibilities, and because I lost you when I was ten years old, you stayed a thousand possibilities. You wove your way into the characters in my stories, filling out their hopes and dreams like they might have been your own. You were the prince who came to rescue me, who swept me away from danger and into safety, peace, and comfort. You settled so solidly into my imagination that it became difficult to recall what was real and what I had made up, but you were always there in the midst of the seemingly unending turmoil of a world for which I did not feel I was built. You faded and faded and faded into a person you never were and never would be, tinged only by the press of your fingers against mine on a playground in the ever-distant past. You became a name contained within a few distinct memories, and I clung to it like little else.
When I was introduced to social media three years after we lost touch, yours was the name for which I searched. I searched and searched and searched, finding no trace that you had ever been. When I found my childhood best friend, it took me embarrassingly little time before I asked about you. She told me you didn’t use social media. She told me that you liked to skateboard. I kept searching. Did I understand that you surely had long-since diverged from the person whom I built in my head? I think so. I think I knew that I had written a version of you that might not have resembled even your shadow. Some part of me still hoped, and so long as I searched and found nothing, I could go on hoping.
There were others. My list of crushes is as long as a young adult novel, and just as dramatic and silly. The one who laughed at my jokes, the one who offered to carry my books, the one who always sat with me during silent, sustained reading time, the one who sang… the other one who sang, the other other one who sang (there were a lot of ones who sang), the one whose fingers danced with such ease on the piano keys, the one who held me against him while he strummed his guitar, the one who bought me cookies at lunch and walked me to class, the one who brought the beauty of the sky to life with his words. I used to keep track.
My heart at first fluttered into the palms of anyone who was kind to me and later who made me remember the world was a place I loved, though seldom anyone who knew my feelings or reciprocated them. I’d scrawl their names on the pages of notebooks, the letters messy and never one and the same. These are the names of those I’ve loved. These are the names of those who love me. These are the names of those who claimed to love me. These are the names of those who see me. Line after line, page after page, I let the ink of my pen paint the proof that they were real.
Your name is not there.
Nine years after I’d last heard your voice, six years after I’d last asked about you, three years since I’d stopped trying to find you, I was walking to class with a friend. “Mia?” you asked, hesitantly. I, bewildered, agreed that that was indeed my name. “It’s T,” you said. The next few heartbeats were a blur. You didn’t have to say anything else. In an instant, I was hugging you, this person who had emerged from a memory. Years of dreaming, of writing, of crafting crashed into reality, and you were there. Time and space had somehow never been enough to set our paths far enough apart to never converge once again.
The last time I saw you, you took me to get lunch at the college cafeteria. You held your arm out to me and allowed me to take it, commenting that you still remembered how to be a guide. I remember the way it felt to touch you in that moment, the texture of your t-shirt, the piping that ran around your elbow. You were real. You were real. I didn’t dream you… or not completely, at least.
You bought my food and asked me about my life. We sat side by side, the sounds of hundreds of voices a comfortable, comforting backdrop. “I have questions,” I wanted to tell you. “It took me half my life, but I finally know what to say.” Conversation came easily. I fought to reconcile you with the person I’d once imagined you to be. You were not my prince Charming come to sweep me away. You were a boy working three jobs while putting himself through college to become a nurse. You wanted to help people, you said. You asked me about my relationship, still a new thing I didn’t quite know how to discuss. I asked you about yours, and you told me of the girl you loved but who had broken your heart. My heart broke for you, believing that the boy I’d imagined deserved no pain or loss. I still struggled to unblur the lines between you and the you I’d built. You talking about your first, your biggest love helped to shatter the allusion somewhat. You’d loved someone who wasn’t me, because of course you had. I had loved people who weren’t you. I had never loved the actual you. The story was only ever a story, and yet I felt the loss and unraveling of it so very deeply.
You walked me to my English class and hugged me outside the door. I remember the tangle of our arms, coats, and backpacks, but you held me tightly before walking away. I never saw or spoke to you again.
It’s been seven years. I found you on Facebook a while ago–you finally gave into social media. I checked your profile once and saw that you were married and just had a little boy. I saw that you had gotten your licenses and degrees. You seemed happy, with your feed full of photos of your small but growing family.
You are not and never have been the boy I loved. You were once the boy who held my hand and against whose skin I believed the constellations to be drawn, but once our paths diverged for the first time, so did the reality of you. You were a boy I loved only in shadow and outline. It was not you who built the foundation for my hopes and wants but rather the way you made me feel. I was seven years old to your eight, but you still showed me the kind of kindness, acceptance, and appreciation I have been seeking for twenty years.
I cried as I read your accomplishments, the life you had built for yourself. I don’t know you. I never have known you. You are far different from the boy I constructed and who followed me through most of my life. Yet, the person that I saw then in truth was one I was glad you had grown to be. I was glad you were not my dreams realized. I was glad I never wrote down your name and instead kept you neatly tucked away in my mind and stories. You deserved to be exactly who you are, not the tangled threads woven into a tapestry of perfection by a girl who, for all her life, had wanted little more than to be shown the kindness you once showed her.
It has been two years since I first began writing this. It has been two years since I let you, both real and imagined, slip away from me. It’s been two years since I set you, and therefore myself, free. Or so I thought.
You see, some of these paragraphs are no longer the shape they once were. The fundamentals remain the same, but the smallest and yet most meaningful details were ones I sat here today and changed. Am became was, have became had. With a sort of pain I don’t think I’ve felt before, I erased my pride and joy for the person whom you’ve become and set it in a past to which I may never find my way back.
How does one grapple with such a tangled web as this? Three versions of you now exist, and I fear none are capable of existing at the same time. There’s the boy on the playground, the boy transformed into my savior, and the man whom I see now.
While my loved ones and I woke up last week with fear and sadness in our hearts, you celebrated. While my friends fight for their very right to exist, you stand as their opposition. While I and many others wonder what might become of us in this new world, you rejoice in the backslide of a still healing nation. While I read headlines and fight the tears of rage and sorrow, you teach your child to hate people like me.
I once loved the shadow of you, and now you are a shadow of a shadow, unrecognizable from the boy who once held my hand. My heart aches for the little girl I once was who thought you were the world. I hurt so deeply for that child who transformed you from skin and bones into ink and paper, who clung to the memory–the idea–of you to keep her safe during the hardest, most chaotic parts of her life.
I knew you once, and the person I knew was kind, and brave, and thoughtful, and caring. I can’t reconcile that version of you with this new reality. Your beliefs don’t make you inherently a bad person, but they are in direct contrast to everything I am and everything I stand for. Seeing the hate you spread, I feel, in some childlike way, as though yet another person who promised to keep me safe and protect me has abandoned me.
But the you who made those promises never existed. You were a product of a desperate, scared, and lonely girl’s imagination and desire for escape. How can I blame you for betraying me when you never truly did? How do I weave these three versions of you together to make sense of it in my own mind? Does the you whom you are now cancel out the you whom I created in my head? I used you as a template, but that is all, and yet I feel like everything I ever believed was a lie.
Surely, there is good in you. Surely, there is that child who sat with me so patiently and taught me to play games, who held me so tightly after I stumbled, shaking, off the stage. Surely, your beliefs don’t tarnish your very being. But they hurt me. They hurt those whom I love.
The threads that once bound us together, those which formed the core of the invisible rope I added later, now unravel at my feet. I watch the aftermath, and I grieve for the child who loved you in her own, innocent way. I grieve for the adolescent who made you into a hero. I grieve for the young adult who once fought so hard to reconcile the two versions of you, never imagining there would be such a controversial third. I grieve for the woman I am now, who does not and never did love you, but who held onto you for so much of her life that it feels as though something essential has been torn away from me. not you, perhaps, but some form of childlike, innocent hope for something better, even if only in imagination.
I occasionally wonder what would have happened if I’d asked a question. I wonder what the story would look like today had I not frozen in fear, so afraid of losing you that I let my silence push you away instead. I don’t regret the way events have unfolded. I wonder, though. I wonder if that moment set the stage for all the ones that would come later. If I had stayed, would it have made a difference? Would it have changed your trajectory? Would it have fundamentally altered who you have now become? Would you have turned your back on me in truth, condemned me for that which I cannot help?
I will never know. Maybe one day I will stop wondering.